Actually we met in 2002..so the relationship did not start till late 2002/early 2003. Did you have the dates correct???

He proposed last year, but I am not sure...so it is not becuase of our personality problems. I was considering more the realistic sides of marriage (i.e. location, life goals, etc).

As for personality, he and others thought I was been too nice to him, which is actually kind of different from what you said. Is it possible that maybe I have the time wrong on the chart?? Or do things sometimes turned out different from the reading?? I am puzzled... I will check the time again.